An experience of ethnological expertise in the Sakha Republic (Yakutia)

The article presents the results of the research conducted at the request of industrial companies developing mineral resources in the deposits of the Sakha Republic (Yakutia). Such research provides materials for submission of company’s documents for obtaining the State commission judgement on ethnological expertise. The experience of assessing the impact of industrial resource development on the ethnological environment obtained in the course of research is a scientific result for the formulation of state industrial policy. The article is aimed at discussing the problems of applying the methodology for calculating the damage to the ethnological environment, developed and approved by the order of the ministry of regional development of the Russian Federation dated December 9, 2009 no. 565. It is revealed that the methodology is excessively focused on the quantitative aspects of damage, leaving aside the issues of public health and quality of life, as well as it is poorly equipped with normative support of indicators taken as the main elements of the calculation model. It is proposed to make significant improvements to the mechanism of determining the damage to the ethnological environment, including the development of the standards to be used in calculations in order to reduce the factor of uncertainty and free interpretation of quantitative indicators, which significantly affects the final amount of compensation.

1. Samsonova IV, Potravny IM, Pavlova MB, et al. the assessment of losses caused to indigenous peoples of the north in the Taimyr Dolgan-Nenets region of Krasnoyarsk Krai due to a diesel fuel spill at chPP-3 in norilsk. Arctic: Ecology and Economics. 2021;11(2):255. available at: http://arctica-ac.ru/docs/journals/42/ocenka-ubytkov-prichinennyh-korennym-malochislennym-narodam-severa-v-taymyrskom-. pdf (in russian).

2. Draft of the Federal Law “on Ethnological Expertise in the Russian Federation”. Federal Portal of Regulatory Legal Acts. available at: https://regulation.gov.ru/regulation/npa/PublicView?npaid=77915

3. Filippova N. How to improve the quality of legal regulation of ethnoexpertise? Expert center “PORA”. 2023: July 14. available at: https://porarctic.ru/ru/comments/natalya-filippova-kak-uluchshit kachestvo-pravovogo-regulirovaniya-etnoekspertizy (in russian).

4. Evaluation. Dictionary on-line. available at: https://1305.slovaronline.com/31%d0%BE%d1%86%d0%B5%d0%Bd%d0%Ba%d0%B0 (in russian).

5. Experts of the Project office for arctic development (Pora). available at: https://porarctic.ru/ru/ (in russian).

6. Ledkov G.P. Indigenous Peoples of the north, Siberia and the Far East Who are We in the modern World? in: Proceedings of the 9th Congress of the Association of Indigenous Peoples of the North, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation, Salekhard, april 5-7, 2021. St. Petersburg; no. 36, 2021:38-42 (in russian).

7. On approval of the methodology for calculating the amount of material losses for the associations of indigenous peoples of the north, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation as a result of economic and other activities of organizations of all forms of ownership and individuals in places of traditional residence and traditional economic activities of indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation. Order of the Ministry of Regional Development of the Russian Federation of December 9, 2009 No. 565. available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LaW_96747/ (in russian).

8. Law of the republic of Sakha (Yakutia) “on Ethnological Expertise”. Information and legal system Garant. available at: https://base.garant.ru/26716249/ (in russian).

9. Pyankov YUV. Experience in applying the methodology for calculating losses caused to associations of indigenous peoples of the north, Siberia (order of the ministry of regional development of the Russian Federation dated 09.12.2009 n 565) in the Khanty-Mansi autonomous okrug-Yugra. in: Indigenous Peoples. Environment. Oil. Law: materials of the scientific and practical conference, Khanty-Mansi autonomous okrug – Yugra, 2018. available at: https://depprirod.admhmao.ru/meropriyatiya/nauchno-prakticheskaya-konferentsiya-korennye-narody-okruzhayushchaya-sreda-neft-zakon/2018-god/doklady-korennye-narody okruzhayushchaya-sreda-neft-zakon/2289486/yu-v-pyankov-opyt-primeneniya-metodiki-ischisleniya-ubytkov-prichinennykh-obedineniyam-korennykh-mal/ (in russian).

10. Regulation on the procedure for compensation of losses caused to indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation, associations of indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation and individuals belonging to indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation as a result of damage to the original habitat of indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation and economic activities of organizations of all forms of ownership, as well as individuals. Resolution of the Government of the Russian Federation of September 18, 2020 No. 1488. available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LaW_362663/5ed200eb9010a6c0bf6076958a0d2aacbc4b3fff/ (in russian).

11. Standard of responsibility of residents of the arctic zone of the Russian Federation in relations with indigenous peoples of the Russian Federation living and (or) carrying out traditional economic activities in the arctic zone of the Russian Federation. Order of the Ministry of the Russian Federation for the Development of the Far East and the Arctic dated November 23, 2020 No. 181. available at: https:// www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LaW_375974/d7d4740028f4f8ad17c1c76bfa5d96b0fa0129db/ (in russian).

12. On the Procedure for organizing and conducting Ethnological Expertise in Places of traditional residence and traditional Economic activity and in territories of traditional nature management of indigenous minority Peoples. Resolution of the Government of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) dated September 6,2011, 428. available at: https://docs.cntd.ru/document/473505816 (in russian).

13. Mindrin AS, Mikhalev OV, Belov VV, et al. Determining the amount of material losses for indigenous Peoples of the north, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation as the users of land and other natural resources in places of their traditional residence and traditional economic activity (methodological recommendations). Moscow; 2008:61 (in russian).